Dornsife Dialogues
Dornsife Dialogues, hosted by the USC Dornsife College of Letters, Arts and Sciences, are conversations among leading scholars and distinguished alumni regarding a wide range of topics relevant to our world today.
Dornsife Dialogues
America at 250: What History Can Teach Us About Our Future
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
As the United States marks its 250th anniversary, what can our history teach us about the nation we are becoming?
Dean James Bullock and USC Dornsife historians Peter Mancall and Nathan Perl-Rosenthal look beyond familiar founding stories to explore how America took shape and how ideas about freedom, citizenship and democracy evolved. What has changed? Which debates remain unresolved? And how can history help us navigate the challenges ahead?
Learn more about the Dornsife Dialogues and sign up for the next live event here.
Narrator:
Welcome to the podcast version of Dornsife Dialogues hosted by the USC Dornsife College of Letters, Arts and Sciences. Conversations feature our distinguished scholars, alumni, and other thought leaders discussing the fascinating issues that matter to you. You can also find video recordings of these discussions on the USC Dornsife YouTube channel. We begin this Dornsife Dialogue with an introduction from Dean James Bullock
James Bullock:
Hi, everyone. Welcome to Dornsife Dialogues America at 250. I'm James Bullock, dean of the USC College of Letters, Arts and Sciences. It's so great to have you here with us. I'm delighted to be joined today by two distinguished historians and longtime colleagues here at USC Dornsife, Peter Mancall and Nathan Perl-Rosenthal. Peter and Nathan also contributed their expertise to the latest USC Dornsife Magazine, which explores America 250. We received so many thoughtful questions from those who registered for today's program, and we will incorporate those questions, throughout our conversation. We will reserve time toward the end for real-time questions if you want to, if you want to pose them. So Peter and Nathan, thank you so much for joining us. And because you guys have been colleagues, you've known each other for a long time rather than me introducing you individually, what I'd like to do is ask each of you to introduce each other, if that makes sense. So let's go ahead and have Nathan introduce Peter and then vice versa.
Nathan Perl-Rosenthal:
Thanks. Thanks so much, Dean Bullock. So it's wonderful to be here. Peter Mancall is, first, Distinguished Professor. The Andrew W. Mellon Professor of the Humanities, the Linda and Harlan Martens Director of the USC-Huntington Early Modern Studies Institute and professor of history, anthropology and economics, and Peter is one of the most prolific and the most generous scholars of early American history around and of environmental and Native history as well. He's written half a dozen single-authored books, including this one, which I just happened to have on my shelf, a very pretty one. The Trials of Thomas Morton, and also the book that he just published, Contested Continent, which I think is behind him over there, over his shoulder. Peter seems to be everywhere, and has done more, I think, in the past 20 years to advance scholarship in early American studies, public-facing and scholarly than nearly anyone else. And I can testify to that personally from the heart, because I started my career, with Peter as my mentor. And he's really a remarkable person and, and a brilliant scholar. So it's really a pleasure to be having this conversation with him.
Peter Mancall:
Well, that's too generous, Nathan, I really appreciate it's hard to follow that, but thank God I've got a lot of material, so it's easy to follow it in some sense.
Peter Mancall:
So it really is a great pleasure to me to introduce to this audience Nathan Perl-Rosenthal, my colleague in the history department, he's also a professor of law and spatial sciences. I actually chaired the committee, the search committee that brought Nathan to USC some years ago. And we have worked very closely over the time we've been together. He's been an incredibly dedicated teacher and remarkable teacher running also our law, history and culture major. I mean, just incredible things. But meanwhile, he's had time to do cutting-edge scholarship from his first major book called Citizen Sailors, which makes us wrestle with the question of what it means to be an American. And what does identity mean of the age of revolution? The Age of Revolutions, a geographically expansive, mind-blowing book got a huge amount of well-deserved attention, sort of pushing the boundaries of how we think about revolutions. And then his newest book, which I think I hope he's going to talk about a bit today, called The Long Revolution. And so, I mean, part of what I'm looking forward to in this conversation is that Nathan's newest work is both of those last books. I sort of pushed the conversation about revolution forward in time, whereas I've been sort of wallowing in the deep past. But before I end this introduction, I do want to say that Nathan's also one of the organizers of what I think is the current issue of the American Historical Review, which is a commemoration of the 250th anniversary for this audience, may be particularly interesting, and it's about 76 objects. And how we think about the material culture of the revolution. And Nathan's done a lot with material culture in his career, so he's a perfect person to help move the air, towards to show how important that topic is. I could go on and on, but I'm going to stop with, I think the spirit of this, James, is that we should have a conversation.
James Bullock:
But, so delighted to be here with Nathan today and also with you, James, I should say, as am I. I mean, I feel so fortunate that I get to participate here, as part of this conversation. And, Peter, by the way, in addition to all of the great scholarship and teaching you have done to elevate the college, you then also brought Nathan to us by chairing that committee. So thank you so much. And thank you for these continued contributions. what I'd like to do now is ask each of you, to share with us a little bit more about your own scholarship and in particular, maybe lean in on some of your recent work. What work and how does that inform the way you think about America's history and America at 250 and why don't I reverse the order?
James Bullock:
Peter, let's go back to you, and then we'll go to Nathan. Okay, great. Oh, thanks, James, I appreciate that. I've started my career, as a historian, thinking I was going to write about, the era of the American Revolution. I had a very influential advisor named Bernard Bailyn, who Nathan also studied with when he was an undergraduate. And I thought I was going to do something about the revolution. But over the course of my career, I moved deeper into trying to understand relations between Native peoples and Europeans, and also deeper into my exploration of how we understand the world that we live in, how people lived in the past. And I've moved back and back and back in time and sort of the culmination of where I am after doing a series of sort of smaller studies is I've written, but by any standards, what have you consider a long book, called Contested Continent, which is volume one of the Oxford History of the United States. And I covered North America from basically 1000 to 1680. And the goal of my book is to have us rethink, that early time period. Now, I want to say for this audience, which tuned in because it is interested in revolution, my new book actually ends in 1680. It ends with a revolution, a revolt, but one that happened in New Mexico. Not one that we talk about in the 13 colonies. And so I try in that book to show the different peoples who came together, often in conflict, often working together and create the foundation for what would eventually, eventually become a nation. So that's kind of where my book, my, my recent book is. But I think I want to hear more from Nathan at this point.
Nathan Perl-Rosenthal:
Well, I want to pick up the autobiographical thread that, Peter just laid down there. You know, I came to this, thinking I was going to originally thinking I was going to do a history of slavery, a long time ago. And, I eventually sort of move backwards from the 19th century into the era of the American Revolution. And I realized, in the process, that although the subjects were different, I had the same fascination. When you think about the history of slavery, you're thinking about an institution that spans continents, that spans centuries, and thinking about the way in which that took a particular form in the United States, in the 19th century. And similarly, my interest in the American Revolution has always been in thinking about the way that the American Revolution is of the world, and not just in the world. Right. The ways in which the revolution is both shaped by and shapes the world, the wider world around it. So that's really a through line of all of my books and the most recent one, the Long Revolution tries to think about, looks at the ways that 19th century people, people in the century after American independence, thought about the revolution and the surprising discovery of this book is that they thought, by and large, that the revolution was still going on decades, if not, a century after 1776. They really do think that the American experiment is an experiment. That is to say, it is a site specific attempt to figure something out, and you do not know where it's going to end. They mean it in the scientific sense. The hard scientific sense. And so the book really tries to think about, using the source, one particular source, 4th of July orations, published 4th of July orations in the century after independence, tries to think about what the kind of implications are of living in a revolution that seems to still be going on long after. We think it's, conventionally think it's over. So that's, you know, that's sort of how I'm, again, thinking about the revolution as something that's much longer than we think, that maybe has much a wider geographic span. And is, of course, because it's going on and on in their lives is shaped by these ongoing influences from abroad.
Peter Mancall:
Yeah. And if I'm going to jump in and just say that one of the things that Nathan and I have in common with other people of our professional generation is that we can't just understand American history in isolation. You can't just look at 13 colonies hugging the Atlantic coast and think you understand the American Revolution. I mean, Nathan's first book took us out into the seas. His second book took us into revolutionary arenas and other places. My work in a series that's this nine states, you know, includes Barbados and Canada and Mexico and Europe and West Africa. Right. I mean, we no longer live in an age where we can just compartmentalize American history as that old traditional. Why did these people in these 13 colonies decide to rebel? And I still think so in that sense. Nathan, I have an intellectual partners. Over the course of the last x number of years we've been together, because I think we see things in a broader context. Right. And I would say it's actually been I mean, I would go a little further and say it's been more than it's been partnership, but it's also been a little bit, brothers in arms, because there is still an amazing amount of resistance to that idea.
Nathan Perl-Rosenthal:
Not I wouldn't say, naive idea that the United States is, you know, stands alone. You know, the cheese stands alone, but a sense that a kind of doubt, really, about, when you try to put the United States together with either, you know, native polities and, you know, native states in the, in the 17th and 18th centuries, which are actually turns out, as Peter has shown, among others, really important in the making of the United States, or when you try to compare the American Revolution, to other revolutions of the late 18th or early 19th centuries. Sometimes people are sort of say, well, yeah, got this great idea. That's really cool. And then sometimes it's sort of like, but isn't it totally different? And there are ways in which it's totally different. But, you know, it's our job as historians to say, well, you know, let's let's get more precise about what's different. Let's get more precise about what's, you know, what, what's exceptional and what's not.
James Bullock:
This is fascinating. And I think we'll get to a lot of these questions as we move forward. Something I wanted to pick up on. You know, Nathan, you talked about this idea of the American experiment. And, you know, from my understanding, you know, let's go back 250 years, the founders really thought of this as an experiment. And I want to plant a seed because, of course, we're representing a Dornsife here, the liberal arts college at USC. the traditions of the liberal arts have been really intertwined with the idea of building a republic and what an informed citizenry is. And this has shaped American democracy for the past hundred and 50 years. What role did the founders feel that a liberal arts education should play in the nation's future, and also just more generally, higher education, and actually not just higher education, education in general for this kind of, virtuous citizenry that they saw as needing to, to thrive as a, as a nation.
Nathan Perl-Rosenthal:
Yeah. I mean, it's a huge it's a huge an important question. And, you know, I think you can Peter can probably speak to some of the kind of deep roots of this that go, you know, it's this is a, this is a deep rooted set of ideas, you know, the kind of the idea of a virtuous citizenry that goes, you know, way into early modern and even medieval Europe. You know, the founders themselves are, by and large, quite well-educated, group. And so they're really thinking about, what it means to be educated and the importance of education for, for making this machinery work. I mean, there's this amazing 4th of July oration by, Horace Mann, a famous educator in the mid 19th century who basically says it's an incredible republic that we've created. But the machinery is really complicated. And in order to make it work, we got to be sure that there are, and, you know, educated people, the public needs to be educated to do that. So I think the work I mean, I would think this, but the work that we're doing in universities, I think is crucial. Peter, any anything to add?
Peter Mancall:
Well, I thought that was a great answer on Nathan's part. I mean, all I would add is, you know, in the period that I have been working on, there's a period from about 1000 to 1680, in terms of institutions of higher education, in what becomes the United States. There's a grand total one. Eventually William & Mary would come on board toward the end of the century, then at the beginning of the 18th. Yale and others would would follow. But I think it's important. Now, I want to also emphasize the central role of education in creating, civilization and, and civil politics. So I think it's hugely important. I do think I would be remiss if I didn't acknowledge that some of that can happen without the formal structure of a college or university. I mean, part of I start my book with the movement of maize, of corn from, the Valley of Mexico to the Mississippi Valley. And one of the points I'm trying to make there is that maize is not just sort of some casual crop that people ran into. It took two generations of scientific observation and cultivation to make it work. Well, that kind of knowledge could advance without what we think of as a formal, you know, college or university. That said, I do think there was a respect for information, respect for historical knowledge, which is embedded in oral histories. It's embedded in the ways that the colonizers talk to each other. It's embedded in the way that enslaved Africans understood their role in this changing world. Nathan sort of alluded to slavery a little while ago. I think it's very important for us to recognize knowledge in all its forms. And this is a this is a plug for what we do at the Dornsife, which I think is we are trying to train the next generation of students of undergraduate and graduate, you know, to be to be knowledgeable and informed and educated and to look for the various ways that one that one gathers information.
James Bullock:
You know, in a society that seems to be changing rapidly, you know, you know, but there was something to be said for when things didn't change as rapidly, information still flowed from one person to another and still informed how we did things. Peter, thanks so much for that perspective. It's so useful. You know your work in the contested continent as you've, as you've laid out, began centuries before the American Revolution. And then, Nathan, your work, in the long revolution examines how Americans continued to interpret and redefine revolution long after independence. Can you speak to that? I mean, it's sort of, you know, how does this widening historical lens, both before and after 1776, change our understanding or the way people might think about the American Revolution and how the nation emerged from that?
Nathan Perl-Rosenthal:
Think one way to think about it is that our kind of actually our focus on 1776 is ahistorical in a funny way. You know, the actors of the late 18th century, and you alluded to this, James, you know, have this very profound historical consciousness. And I would just connect this also to what Peter was saying. You know, if you live in an oral society, you can't not or, you know, what sort of oral-dominant society where you, you know, stories and chains of tradition or the way that, you know, things not like pulling a book off the shelf. You have a kind of intuitive sense of, of the depth of the past, right? That it's, you know, you have this sense that the story that you heard has been passed down from generation to generation. You have this sense of the chain of transmission, maybe. So I would say that the, you know, the people in the late 18th century really have a very strong sense of the kind of the historicity and the longness of the, of the trajectories. And I think actually, in a funny way, I mean, you know, here we are having a, a discussion about 1776 on the 250th anniversary. But they weren't thinking in those kinds of terms. They weren't thinking, know, let's commemorate the thing that happened 250 years ago. For some of them, it's a very living. It's very much a living thing. I think that's they're much more, in some ways, connected to these kind of distant pasts in the pre-modern world than than I think we are.
James Bullock:
Nathan, I'll interject because, Peter, I want to hear what you have to say, but I just want to follow up with that. what have we lost? I mean, have we lost something? And in not seeing ourselves as a living experiment, I mean, I know you can't speak for all Americans or in the nation, but just from your perspective, or maybe more specifically, why why are we no longer thinking of ourselves as a living experiment?
Nathan Perl-Rosenthal:
Yeah, I mean, I, I think there is, you know, there was a lot of discussion about this, actually, I would say from the right and from the left, interestingly, the sense that in the 20th century, maybe in the 19th century too, but especially in the 20th century, you know, we've lost touch with certain kinds of organic kind of, you know, I would say even generational structures you think about, you know, the way that American families changed over the course of the 20th century becoming much more nuclear and much less multi-generational. You think about the way that the information economy changed. So, you know, you wouldn't read, you know, a really old book you'd read what you'd increasingly read, the new bestseller that comes out right. This is the world we live in. And so I think, I think actually, interestingly, from both right and left now, there's a lot of critique of that, a kind of sense that we need to reconnect to this long. Do you have this long, time frame? Especially since, look where, you know, we're all experiencing right now, climate transformation, which, you know, makes you think about the long term, because it's these are long term processes. So I, I do think we're having a bit of a return maybe to this kind of historical consciousness. And I think it's, it's salutary because it allows you to kind of think bigger in a way that allows you to think beyond your family, yourself, your small community. It allows you to say, you know, actually, this is connected to a much bigger trajectory, a much bigger story. And to think about, yeah. How to how to work with that, I suppose.
James Bullock:
Peter, you know, let's go back to this question about widening the historical lens and in particular of your work that goes back way before 1776. How does that, you know, how does that inform the way we were thinking about things?
Peter Mancall:
Yeah, yeah, thanks for asking that. And I really that was a great answer, Nathan. I have to say,
Peter Mancall:
So, you know, every book, no matter what the author tells you, every book the author is writing for a specific sort of intended audience in mind. And the book that I just wrote is part of a series and a series called The Oxford History of the United States. And this series was originated long ago. It's still not finished. But it is a certain way of writing, thinking, and writing about the past, and it emphasizes narrative and sort of telling the arc of a broad story over time. And knowing that my book is has the title, the words United States on the cover, even though there's no United States in my book. You know, I wanted to sort of say, okay, well, what themes can I develop in this work that help us understand what would eventually become a nation and eventually, frankly, help my book fit into this series, which is about the history of the United States. And I emphasize in there, you know, a few core ideas, but it's already come up here, you know, in our conversation. I mean, one I mentioned before, but I talked about the example of movement of maize and culture moving. I'm talking about how people reshape landscapes for economic needs. There are a number of things that happened in the period that I write about that do have, I think, a permanent impact on what becomes United States or arguably the world. One of them is the is the spreading importance to the economy and the spreading poison of the enslavement of Africans, first of native peoples, then of Africans. Right. Which really does create the roots of much of the crisis of modern day inequality. You know, related to that, the reason enslavement spread across the Americas is because Europeans, when they arrive, wanted to extract whatever wealth they could from the natural world. They saw you see this from literally the moment Columbus arrives and announces to the world, here's this fantastic place. We didn't know about it here, all these things, let's take them. And by the way, let's capture some of the people and we can enslave them to from that moment, right from this idea, which then becomes enshrined in European culture in something called the doctrine of discovery, sort of, you know, which the Vatican puts forward in 1493. There is this notion that Europeans and what they stand for is what the world is supposed to be, right? And that is supposed to be to spread Christianity. And for peoples who are not Christian, they would, as happened in the period I discuss, Europeans saw them in subordinate positions. So these different things about enslavement and extraction of wealth really are foundational to what to our modern, our modern world. And they lay out certain attitudes. Their environmental historians will say, oh, well, you know, the most important thing that understand changes in the environment really stem from the industrial revolution of the late 18th century. And that is a very important. And in terms of climate change, this revolution is hugely important. But the attitudes that shaped the Industrial revolution come from an earlier time period, and they are sort of foundational to what I write about in Contested Continent.
James Bullock:
Fascinating, Peter, and, you know, a lot of the themes that you were discussing, relate to this kind of broader fact that the United States is part and has been part of a of a world where we have a very complicated, you know, changing environment. And you guys had both touched on this before. But, you know, the American Revolution is often presented as this self-contained national story. And but you're you're talking about the idea that, it's really this broader Atlantic and global context of change that. we should be thinking about how can you help articulate that a little bit more? What what are we missing if we're sort of thinking of the American Revolution as this sort of little bubble that's happening in New England as opposed to, you know, a global phenomenon?
Peter Mancall:
First of all, James, I have to say that people in Virginia be very upset if they felt sorry. Yeah, I don't know. I probably should have said Virginia. That's right. That's okay, that's okay. I'm just. I'm just letting you know that there are these there are you go back into the older literature. There are these competing stories about founding of colonies, where there is a New England version and there is a Chesapeake version. I mean, there's you know, they really battled over that and they continue to battle. The people in Virginia will still tell you they had the first Thanksgiving, you know, on and on. Anyway, putting that, let me just say I was born in North Carolina, so I'm really I don't know why I went there. I should have I should have definitely, gone further south, but. Yeah. Sorry. Go ahead. I think part of I think one of the enduring challenges, opportunities, you know, that confront has been trying to understand the revolution is that we if there was this incredible flourishing of ideas and those ideas did create eventually this document in the first and declaration, then the Constitution, which have had a big impact on the on the country. And I'm going to leave it to Nathan to talk about those. But they did have a big impact. And they did, even though they were, as Nathan pointed out, really smartly pointed out, they were very concerned about history. They also had the sense that they were sort of creating a world, a new right, as they would sort of talk and saw this as a new birth of things. That said, for what I do, I think and I think what Nathan does, we're both trying to say, yes, important things now, important and good and do not necessarily overlap here. Important things happened in those 13 colonies in the 1770s and 1780s, and they did shape a lot of what happened. And, you know, a lot, a lot of things didn't happen that might have made the world better. So the declaration refers to native peoples as merciless Indian savages. And when the founders in Philadelphia take out a possible clause to end the slave trade, they are making real choices that shape what happened afterwards and reflect what happened before. And we need to remember. And this is why Nathan's work is so important. We need to remember that the national myth concentrates on people who live between the Atlantic and the crest of the Appalachian Mountains, clustered mostly in New England and around the Chesapeake. But they are part of a much more dynamic world. Dynamic, economically dynamic. Intellectually, there are a lot of things going on, and you can't just tell the story anymore, as the revolution is a New England story. That or the next revolution, the Chesapeake story, you can. There's plenty of opportunity for biographical work, how to do so and so. I understand the revolution. Absolutely. But as a larger story, and I think that's where Nathan, I really have a foundational agreement. You know, we just can't look at it as isolated to a moment of founding that took place from 1776 to 1787, even if it took place a lot of it in my hometown of Philadelphia.
Nathan Perl-Rosenthal:
Yeah. So, I mean, I, I couldn't agree with that more. And I think the, one of the I'm just going to sort of add the projection for trying to project it forward a little bit from where we, from where we are. Peter is kind of taking us up to 1776. And I guess I just wanted to say before I say anything else, just to take a step back as, scholars, this is something that when I teach, like history 100, that this is one of the first things I tell them, like, what is it that historians actually do? Because I think sometimes people think what we do is know a lot of facts. It turns out you do need to know a lot of facts. But what we're really interested in is explanation. Its historical explanation is why does something happen? What makes it happen, what are the inputs that produce it? And in that sense, you know, in the same way that, you know, natural scientists are interested in trying to understand, right, how, geological forces produce certain kinds of effects, how, you know, natural selection produces certain kinds of, life forms. We're interested in thinking about the kind of forces that are working, on, events in the past. And if you think only in terms of the eastern seaboard of the United States. Well, first of all, it's impossible. You basically have this if you're thinking about even the American Revolutionary War. Let's just stick with the chronology Peter described. You want to explain why the American Revolution happens and how it succeeds. Good luck doing that without constantly making reference to the wider world. I mean, you know, I think probably everybody, who's watching this has heard of the, the Tea Act or the Boston Tea Party. That's a story about India. It's a story about, the Netherlands, and it's a story about, Britain as much as it's a story about what happens in Boston Harbor, in, in 1773. So, you know, you're constantly having to bring that in. If you think about how is the American Revolutionary War won? Well, it turns out that without French arms, enormous quantities of French equipment, and then an enormous French fleet and a pretty sizable French expeditionary force, pretty clear that they, you know, the Americans probably wouldn't have won the war. Those were crucial elements. So it's baked into the story. But what's really remarkable, I think, is that as you go forward, even from 1783, the peace treaty that ends the Revolutionary War, recognition of the United States, American politics is constantly responding, which is sort of what I'm most interested in, is constantly responding to inputs to, forces from outside of that eastern seaboard region. You can think about the forces from, you know, the West, which is to say, everything west of the Appalachians or south of, you know, Georgia basically, which is Spanish territory mostly, and sometimes French territory in this period. They're reacting to things going on in the Caribbean. Yeah. Very intensely during the 1790s. The Haitian Revolution is an enormous influence on early American politics. And then not to say nothing of the French Revolution or the Napoleonic regime and the Napoleonic Wars. So really it's I think it's not so much that, you miss a lot, if you don't integrate this wider world into thinking about the revolution, it's inexplicable without it. So your choices are actually take it all on board and really think about what is this wider world look like. What are the inputs, what are the forces that are in play around the United States? Or you can just focus on the eastern seaboard and constantly these sort of like, you know, marionettes entering from stage right, solving problems, creating problems, and then disappearing into the ether. But that's not a very satisfying if you've tried to teach it. It's a very unsatisfying, result. You know, you're sort of like. And then suddenly the French appear, you know, and then five minutes later, they're gone. And it's just. It doesn't make any sense. So I think it really it's actually there. It's just a matter in some ways of recognizing it's there ness, and, and saying, yeah, actually, this, you know, this country from its founding has always been in this matrix as much larger matrix of nations, of empires and, you know, it's fascinating to understand how it comes to take the form it does in that within that matrix.
James Bullock:
That's wonderful. Okay. So this is this has been fascinating. One thing I want to do is I want to shift the question a little bit, because I want to make sure we're responsive to some of the questions that were posed by the audience before. As we were leading up and, and several attendees asked specifically about political divisions. So the question is whether the United States has ever been as politically divided as it is today. And then what kind of revolutionary era? And then maybe this broadened idea of time, you know, from 1776, forward and backward, what can those periods of intense division teach us about the current moment? Are there historical parallels that are useful, where comparisons might be misleading? I'll, I'll leave it to both of you to answer any, any way you feel is appropriate.
Peter Mancall:
And let me just remind, you know, this audience, I'm a historian primarily of the 16th and 17th centuries. And I'm no more than a casual observer of what's going on today. But, you know, all this talk about the divided society we live in, I don't want to minimize and I don't want to minimize some of the really terrible, violent things that have happened in recent years based on political hatred of one kind or another. I will say that some historical perspective, but I'm not trying to minimize the divisions, but some historical perspective may be useful. I write about a time period, you know, in which political divisions fueled really, terrible violent acts. I mean, really terrible violent acts that I think would shock modern sensibilities. And though I'm not saying we are leading in that direction, because I certainly hope we are not, I do think we need to understand. Or maybe I leave it to the audience to try to figure out, you know, how we understand the divisions we have now and put them in historical context? You know? you know, Nathan is a brilliant historian of, you know, the revolution. What? Follow the revolution. Well, two generations after the revolution, this country broke apart into a civil war. people talk about how divided we are now. You know, I very much hope and I don't see. But I'm a historian. I look at the past, I don't see that happening again. Right. So I do think some perspective is important and some balance is important and some ways of trying, to talk to each other, you know, is really important.
Nathan Perl-Rosenthal:
And I don't want to go off on a moralistic rant. So I'll stop for the moment.
Nathan Perl-Rosenthal:
Now, I really want to underscore one of the things Peter said, which is, you know, this is one of the things that, star and professors always say is you like the things you don't know. You know, you know, as Peter was saying, the 17th century, the 16th century, God help us. I mean, these are deeply violent periods, and people are coming to blows. Wars began. There's extraordinarily violence within societies based on things like religious difference, which, know, are hard to even wrap your head around. Right. The idea that, Protestants and Catholics could be so violently hostile to each other that you would just you would murder each other in cold blood when given the chance. But that's you know, standard fare in the 17th century. One of the things that happens in the 18th century, this is why I work on the 18th century. Because it's nice. Not like this, you know, murder some 17th century. I just, you know, this is this is what historians do is, you know, I my century is better than your century is part of our part of our game. The part of what happens in the 18th century is a real concerted effort to set those set boundaries. The, the, the area of debate, to set boundaries on what politics can touch, what politics can shape. So you see it in the US Constitution, right? Freedom of speech, freedom of religion, separation of, church and state. These are, obviously now, and always have been in some ways contested concepts. But the idea behind them is, listen, the state just has no business looking into making windows into men's souls, as they say in the 16th century. You know, it's not our business what people do in their religious lives. And that actually doesn't. It seems like a very trite idea now, but actually, even in the 18th century, it's a kind of radical idea. The idea that, you know, it doesn't matter what your faith is. And in the 70, in the 18th century, it's, you know, Jews, atheists, non-Christians who are kind of people ask questions like, does this mean that, like, you know, you could be a Jew and a congressman? Which is an actual live question in the 18th century? But then it becomes a question about, Latter-day Saints in the early 19th century. Are they can they, you know, be can they have representatives in Congress? Can they be good citizens even though they are, you know, they embrace this faith that for, Orthodox Protestants in the, you know, in the 1830s and 40s is regarded as heretical. So so I think, yes, division, but I think also in the, in the 18th century and in the process that both Peter and I have studied, people have been wrestling with this. We're wrestling this in the period that we're looking at. They are already wrestling with unbelievably intense violence and division, and they're trying to figure out ways to kind of not to make everyone agree, but to move those disagreements into a part of life, into a part of society where they can exist and society can continue to carry on and politics can carry on peaceably. So there are models there, I think, for how to how to try to think about this, right, to try to say not that, you know, we're going to enforce agreement, not that we're going to push people out, but we're going to say, you know, there are neutral spaces. And this is, of course, something that a lot of people just come back to your earlier, observation. James. Right.
James Bullock:
Know, this is what I think a lot of us, the ideal of the university is that this is a neutral space in a way that this is a space where we can have these conversations. And in principle, nothing is off limits, right? That you can have that conversation.
James Bullock:
I mean, Nathan, that's so interesting to me because it's almost like there's something patriotic in a university holding itself up as a neutral space. And that it helps maybe sort of dampen divisions.
Nathan Perl-Rosenthal:
Is that fair to say, or am I going that far?
Nathan Perl-Rosenthal:
No, no, I think that's absolutely right. I mean, I think the university's the ideal of the university is it is very much, an ideal of a kind of, public school. I mean, the ideal of the modern university, which must be separated from the ideal of the early modern university, which is a basically or a theological schools. So the ideal of the modern university, I think, is very much a kind of, idealized version of a certain kind of patriotism. Yeah. And yeah, I think it is, I think I yeah, I think I'm an agree. I think patriotic is a good way to put it. The university, the neutral university is a patriotic institution.
James Bullock:
Well, great. I might use that going forward. So, if you don't mind, I want to ask about something very specific. When we were talking about the visions, I mean, famously, John Adams and Thomas Jefferson were quite adamantly fighting at one point in their respective careers, but they ended their lives with this famous correspondence where they were writing letters and they seem to have reconciled. Do you have anything to add about that, because you had a place where you had this very divisive relationship that through, I think, talking to each other, or at least writing letters to each other, they figured out how to work together again, or at least see, I understand that they were after the same thing in some broader sense. Any commentary on that relationship?
Nathan Perl-Rosenthal:
I mean, it's a fascinating relationship. And, you know, one of the best parts about it is that when it ends, right, that they both that they both die on July 4th, 1826 on Independence Day, each thinking that the other is still is still living. it's hard to generalize from some such specific, you know, models. I mean, Jefferson and Adams are very exceptional. Unusual? Remarkable people. You know, in a way, I think, if one again pulls the lens out a little bit from them, part of what happens in that the period that they're having this, this rapprochement, this is used to be called by American historians. I don't know if this is still used. The era of good feelings, from about 1816 to about 1828. Because basically there's only one party, the kind of the intense divisions that had existed in the early Republic, but kind of are absorbed in this kind of single party world. And so in that sense, the Adams Jefferson kind of rapprochement is part of a broader sort of unification. And then as Peter pointed out, of course, it then, you know, it then falls apart again and again. It's this, this bad seed, this, you know, sort of seed of evil, of slavery, that, that, that ultimately, you know, regrows, with full force and, you know, in the early 19th century, but there is a kind of universe in which, yeah. You know, the United States could have been kind of a one party happy one party state. And Jefferson and Adams are kind of emblematic of that. I don't know, Peter. Do you agree? I know, I mean, that maybe that's too erratic. No, no, I like that. I, I was going to jump in with a very specific thing from those letters that people don't tend to, to write about or think about.
Peter Mancall:
Actually, I use to some of my books, there's one moment where John Adams, famous for all sorts of reasons, John Adams, decides he's going to write a local history of where he lives in his post-presidency years. And it turns out this is a spit of land. Braintree, outside of Boston. That was a scene of a very infamous moment in the history when the pilgrims still roamed the earth in the 1620s, but a guy named Thomas Morton set up a maypole and danced around it anyway. Morton, one of the great characters in American history. Anyway, Adams is writing this local history, and before Morton came on the scene, there was a guy named a Captain Wollaston. And there's only story that Adams could find is that Captain Wollaston went to Virginia. So Adams, in the midst of letters about other things, says, oh, by the way, it says to Jefferson, do you know this? Captain Wollaston? And Jefferson sort of goes into the, you know, consultant's library, you know, to be a foundation for proconsul. Yeah. To say, oh, no, I'm not fine much. And they go back and forth and they go back and forth in this way that though they were political rivals, there also this there's also this kind of quirky intellectual friendship slash rivalry, which they wanted to one up themselves. Who knew more about this obscure character from the past? Sadly, they stopped writing about poor Captain Wollaston. He disappears back into the mysteries of history. So anyway, I love that, I don't know if that's any lessons for any of us to take with us, but I love that kind of detail.
James Bullock:
It's fascinating. But let me ask a question that we got from the audience.
James Bullock:
And this is building on the discussion of Americans, thinking about politics on a grand scale. And over the long term, what can history teach us about the importance of local and state government? Should Americans devote more attention to those levels of government, rather than focusing primarily on the federal government? So what is local government versus the federal government?
Peter Mancall:
I guess from a historical perspective, how much does that mattered?
Peter Mancall:
All right. I'm going to jump on that first, Nathan, I'll be quick on this one. So if you look at maps from the time period that I write about, say, the 17th century, you'll see North America divide it up, you know, England or whatever, New Spain, New France, here, these European names on maps, European names on territories that are dominated by native peoples and native tribes and nations that have been there for a long time and are still there. And one of the important ways to understand what's really happening on the ground is you can't just say, oh, I'm a representative of France, I'm represent of England, and this is our territory. These people are going out into real worlds or entering into politics. They need to understand. And it's one of the points that I make in my book. When you look at places like Roanoke and other lost colonies, they typically are lost because these Europeans. But the sort of arrogant notion that this territory didn't pay attention to local politics. Now, that's not an exact analogy to what's going on now, but I did once live in the congressional district of Tip O'Neill, you know, and all politics is local to a certain extent. And I think there's something to be said. And I think our obsession with politics at the federal level kind of blinds us to the importance of what happens in localities and states.
Nathan Perl-Rosenthal:
Okay. So I'm going to I'm going to riff on that if I can, a little bit. So, you know, I think one of the, one of the things that Peter kind of drew out there is that the pre-modern world, let's say the world before 1800 or 1850, is a really local world. It's not that there isn't like mass media, certainly in the 18th century, there is mass media in some sense. You know, you have certainly a big circulation newspapers and things like that. But by and large, this is a world that's very rooted in local places and that's really in continuity with the world that Peter was just depicting of this early settlement where, you know, you, you, you know, if you lived in, Charlottesville or, you know, or Jamestown, you know, your world was dominated by what was right around you, right? What was proximate to you? It's not that you weren't affected by these kind of wider currents, but the thing you would really know, the thing you would really be kind of immersed in as the world right around you. And I think the idea that we have now that, you know, you're watching the news and you're kind of immersed in what's going on in the Strait of Hormuz, you know, and all you can think about is the Strait of Hormuz. And you wake up in the morning worrying about the Strait of Hormuz. This would have been, I think, quite alien to our early modern, our pre-modern ancestors. in that sense, I think there is this real localism, and I see that translated in the 19th century, especially so in the book that I just published. It's based on these 4th of July orations and those orations, you know, we think about them or you think about 4th of July orations as being, you know, these kind of big official things. It's actually a super bottom up tradition in this era. I have through the, the 19th century until reconstruction. So for 100 years after American independence, most 4th of July orations are organized by local committees, sometimes by towns, often by like activist groups or workingmen's associations, kind of like community groups. And they'll just throw together their own 4th of July celebration and name an orator. And it's, you know, it's super hyper local. It's not. Sometimes it's even more than just a town. Sometimes it's like a neighborhood of a town. You know, the people who give the, the 4th of July oration in, in Jamaica Plain, outside Boston. You know, we're always, you know, sniffing about the Boston orators because they're, you know, they're all fancy and whatever. So there's a lot of that. It's like this hyper localism. And what I think it creates is a kind of, an accountability, maybe, to your local community. Right. You imagine these orders actually standing in front of a large part of the local community? They have to say things that are not going to offend the people in front of them. And they got to try to say something that might interest them. So I think the idea to come back to the original question, the idea of kind of localism, I would say, is, again, a kind of coming back to localism, a localism that, again, has a very long history in world history, and certainly even in this, in this continent, in this country, this idea that local communities are really primary and we look to them to explain to us how we should, how we should live, what the sort of the right thing to do is, so, yeah, I think there are and I think there was a movement in that direction to try to kind of reconnect with that, with that kind of localism. And I think it's, I think it's probably good.
James Bullock:
Let me build on that, because one of the things you've touched on as part of that question is information culture, where we had societies shaped by oral communication, then print and now digital media, how would these shifts, you know, changed, who participated in the public debate and how political ideas spread? How does that transition, you know, how does that transition play out?
Peter Mancall:
Yeah. It's interesting question. Also, I think it was, James, I like how you phrased that. You know, you went from oral to print to digital and I thought you were going to go one step more and just say, and now nonfiction, that is the rise of AI creating stories and explanations. I mean, it does seem I mean, look, I am no theorist of current information technology, but it does seem to me we are on a another turning point. I think I think it's important. Now, granted, you know, Nathan and I spend a lot of time all historians spend a lot of time. You know, in archives and really, you know, really good, really important historical works, you know, really comes from the fact of how historians know their subject. Right? I mean, we really try to get in deep. And so in my research, again, from this earlier period, I do think that the rise of print is really important. It it's important for spreading among Europeans, ideas about the Americas and go adding them to enter into expeditions of conquest, exploration conquest and colonization. It's important, oral culture doesn't disappear. I mean, I think that was one of Nathan's points, right? Yeah. We're still talking to each other. And even though, you know, we may text each other or maybe I can't tell AI slop from a legitimate invitation because every author gets these every day flooding our inboxes from talking to each other, you know, is important. I mean, I'm traveling to East Coast, you know, next week to talk in person, you know, to one of the native communities to talk with people in this native community about something that happened there in 1623, and to talk to people at a nearby college. Yeah, to talk about sort of a broader arc of things. Well, you know, in some theoretical universe, they could just read my book. That's very different than communicating orally, you know, it's you have to learn, you know, all of us as scholars and authors, you know, we're always reading a room, whether we know it or not. We just some of us do it better than others.
James Bullock:
And I think that personal communication is still important. And as we enter into this new when to me scary age of AI, I think that interpersonal is going to be more and more important. That's my personal take. Again, not a scholar of information technology.
James Bullock:
What if, if you don't mind, I mean, maybe for both of you, you know, since you bring it up, Peter, you know, we're experiencing you know, we don't know exactly what's happening with AI right now, but clearly something big is changing. It's affecting so many pieces of our lives. But there have been major technological changes, that have affected folks throughout history, including, you know, the availability of lots of printed media, for example, are there any lessons from history or at least is there anything in history that might rhyme with what's what's happening now in terms of scope and impact?
Nathan Perl-Rosenthal:
I don't want to be a Pollyanna, but I want to just really underscore and try to maybe just abstract a little bit what, Peter was saying, which is that this idea of a kind of succession, it's almost a it's almost a version of supersessionism, the idea, theological idea that one religion kind of replaces another. It takes over, the true becomes the true church. You know, it's, I think deeply faulty. You know, the, the, the history of communication, especially of transmission of information is one of it's kind of layering, a kind of, thick painting in which one layer goes on top of the other, and you can still often see the under layers. And as Peter was saying, they often play distinctive roles. So, you know, you think about the development of print in the, you know, in the 1615 16th century. You think about the development of, of movable type. you think about, the steam press. I mean, I'm literally just talking about printing technology here. You think about Linotype, you think about. Right, digital, printing machines, I mean, each one of these is in its own way, deeply disruptive, to the kind of existing modalities of communication. And what you find is a large part of supersession, right? That older technologies are replaced with newer ones. Right. You don't get a newspaper that's printed on a wood block anymore. But there's still woodblock printing. It's still serves a purpose. It still has its, its kind of corner. And similarly, I guess I'm a little bit of, maybe a little bit of, a truther about, about the kind of succession of technologies. Right. There's this idea that, you know, the new technologies just sweep away everything before it. And that's really not what I see. I remember one instance, a kind of echo of revolutions. Moment, when the color revolutions happened, the early in the Arab sort of the Arab Spring, early 2000, 20 tens. There was a lot of talk about, you know, this was sort of the height of Facebook and the like to say, oh, you know, the whole thing was being organized on Facebook. And then there was an article that I read in the newspaper which said, which actually interviewed a bunch of people in one of these demonstrations, and not a single one of them had heard about it from Facebook. They had all heard about it from their neighbor, from their friend, from their community group. So it's not that there isn't stuff going on on these networks, but I think we often underestimate we kind of want to underestimate, the, the durability and the kind of endurance, as Peter was saying, of, of the face to face of the old tech. And again, I don't want to sound like a complete Pollyanna, you know, just, you know, everything's great and everything's fine because obviously, as you said, you know, AI is the sort of transition to AI is is deeply disruptive of a lot of things. But I do think so long as humanity survives that there will be a kind of, adaptation and transformation and not a kind of erasure, you know, at least that's my that's my optimistic take from what a what a great perspective.
James Bullock:
Thank you so much for that, Nathan. And so, so Peter, we're almost out of time here. But, Peter, I did want to sort of ask you specifically about what's happening with commemorating America at 250 through the LA 2026 initiative, cultural institutions across Southern California are interpreting this 250th anniversary from lots of different perspectives. what can these approaches teach us about regional identity and historical memory?
Peter Mancall:
Yeah, thanks for that question, James. So the USC-Huntington Early Modern Studies Institute has coordinated programs through a grant from the National Endowment for the Humanities called LA 2026 and six cultural institutions, one of which is the USC Libraries. Have each sort of had programs that we've helped organize to talk about. So the USC Libraries said, well, what was going on in Los Angeles in 1976? That was the theme of their thing. The Huntington Library, one of our partners, has an exhibit that stretches from ancient oak trees. You know, you know, to a Woody Guthrie guitar, the Autry Museum, another one of our partners is trying to set up what is the meaning of liberty in a place like Los Angeles? Stretch over a couple of hundred years. The folks over at the Mission San Gabriel Arcángel, the oldest mission in the LA area, redesigned their museum to really on using the anniversary as an occasion to think. How can we rethink how can we tell the story in this religious space? How can we tell a story about what? What the mission created this mission meant? Because any one of those California history knows this is a very contentious topic. So one of the things that we found that we found in coordinating these programs is that people are taking the ideas or they think or the ideas of 1776, and they're interpreting them broadly. And it does speak to sort of the living tradition of 76, you know, all of the declaration, not necessarily hyper praise, but, you know, as saying, okay, this is a moment that mattered and articulated certain ideas. We can use these ideas to think about, you know, how do we think about where we live? That's what the Autry Museum is about, you know, how do we think about these things broadly? That's what the Huntington exhibit is about. So I think that the ideas as they're expressed in 76 still inform us, even though we don't in many ways think like the people who created those words in ’76.
James Bullock:
So those commemorations you were describing it, I mean, it's something that you've studied explicitly, Nathan. In terms of other generations, how can those commemorations you've studied teach us about, well, what we're doing now in commemorating, the 250th?
Nathan Perl-Rosenthal:
You know, I think one of the most important elements of those commemorations, and I think that's been one of the hard, the tricky things about, this anniversary.
Nathan Perl-Rosenthal:
But it was a problem with the, the previous anniversary 50 years ago, in 1976, is there's this real. And I think I want to come back to what Peter was saying about Mission San Gabriel Arcángel. You know, there's this idea that commemorating the revolution means kind of casting your mind back and imagining yourself, you know, in, in Philadelphia or wherever, you know, wearing knee breeches. And I actually think what's striking about these commemorations in the 19th century is that's not at all what they're doing. Practically every 4th of July oration, until 1876 or so, starts with something along the lines of, I am not going to talk about the American Revolution. And they actually don't they focus on the present, most famously, Frederick Douglass in 1852 says, my subject today is the present, the ever living present, which is with what matters. So in a way, I think, we can best commemorate the revolution, perhaps. And I think this is part of what Peter was pointing to there in this mission, San Gabriel, commemoration by thinking about it, in our world, by thinking about it as living history, by thinking about it as something which we are still engaged with rather than, you know, this kind of golden hued, you know, marble hewn, and also very dusty, distant past. So that's the way I think that's the lesson I take from these, from these 19th century commemorations, that it it should be living for us as much as possible.
James Bullock:
I love that, and I can think of no better point to end on bringing together what Peter was talking about and what Nathan, you just said about this word of living.
James Bullock:
You know, again, this living experiment that we're still within. So I wanted to thank both Peter and Nathan for sharing your expertise, with us today and helping us think more deeply about America 250, for the audience to continue to explore timely ideas with USC Dornsife scholars and alumni, I encourage you to subscribe to the Dornsife Dialogues podcast and visit our online library of previous conversations, So again, thank you both. Thank thank you to everyone for joining us. And as always, fight on.
Narrator:
We hope you enjoyed this episode of the Dornsife Dialogues podcast. Please leave us a rating and a review wherever you listen. Thank you for your support. Fight on.